Property and Income of Religious Institutions: Public or Private
Abstract
The article considers the sources of income of religious institutes, origin and destination of Church property and the withdrawal of state ownership of church property (secularization) as a special form of nationalization. The analysis is performed on the example of the Orthodox Church, for this the sources of Canon law and the historical aspects have been studied. The author analyses the sources of acquisition of church property, makes the conclusion about the public mission of the church property. That means the seizure of church property generates budget expenditure commitments. The article describes the sources of church property, legal forms of its seculyarization, and also aims of church property. Acquisition of temple property is tracked from the oldest times but it could be made by law only from the moment of the Milan edict (313). The main sources of its acquisition are: donations, inheritance, purchase or creation, gifts from the state treasury. The mission of church property is defined by internal rules of Church, but it is not certain resolution in the the canonical law, despite clear understanding of due and undue use. Seculyarization is a historical form of nationalization, its character depends on an involvement of the state into affairs of church management. The seculyarization history in countries of Western Europe is connected with a problem of „killing” of church property for a civil using. In the East (the countries of East Christian religion) such problem didn't stand owing to bilateral process of donation and withdrawal of property between the church and the state.
References
Alekseev A. I. (2014) Iosif Volotskiy [Joseph Volotsky]. Moscow: Molodaya Guardia, 335 p. (in Russian)
Bolotov V. V. (2002) Sobranie tserkovno-istoricheskikh trudov. Lektsii po istorii Drevney Tserkvi [Collection of Works on Church History. Lectures on Ancient Church]. Moscow: Martis, 422 p. (in Russian)
Bulgakov S. N. (2007) Istoriya ekonomicheskikh i sotsial'nykh ucheniy [History of Economic and Social Theories]. Moscow: Astrel, 988 p. (in Russian)
Florensky P. (2009) Predpolagaemoe gosydarstvennoye ustroistvo [Projected State Form] Moscow: Gorodetz, 205 p. (in Russian)
Isayev M.A. (2012) Istoria rossiyskogo gosudarstva i prava [History of Russian State and Law] Moscow: Statut, 838 p. (in Russian)
Kartashev A. V. (1977) Ocherki po istorii Russkoy tserkvi [Essays on the History of Russian Church]. Moscow: Terra, 685 p. (in Russian)
Kozyrin A.N. (2014) Privatizatsiya i natsionalizatsiya [Privatization and Nationalization]. Kazna i byudzhet [Treasury and Budget. D. L. Komyagin (ed.)]. Moscow: Nauka, 595 p. (in Russian).
Lopukhin A. P. (2005) Zakonodatel'stvo Moiseya [Moses' Laws]. Moscow: Zertzalo Publishing, 328 p. (in Russian)
Protoiereus Vladislav Tsypin (2012) Kanonicheskoe pravo [Canon Law]. Moscow: Sretenski monastiry, 100 p. (in Russian)
Rev. Bishop Porphyrius (2007) Istoriya Afona [History of Athons]. Moscow: Dar Publishing, 1087 p. (in Russian)
Romanenko E.V. (2011) Vzglyady Nila Sorskogo na problemy lichnoy sobstvennosti monakhov i korporativnoy sobstvennosti monastyrey [Views of Nil Sorsky to the Personal Property of Monks and Corporate Property of Monasteries]. Prepodobnye Iosif Volotskiy i Nil Sorskiy [Rev. Joseph Volotsky and Nil Sorsky. Collection] Moscow: Volotsky Monastery Publishing, 286 p. (in Russian)
Sergeevich N.S. (2007) Drevnosti russkogo prava [Antiquities of Russian Law] Moscow: Public Historical Library, 595 p. (in Russian)
Suvorov N.S. (2004) Uchebnik tserkovnogo prava [Canon Law. Textbook]. Moscow: Zertzalo, 504 p. (in Russian)
Smolich I.K. (1996) Istoriya Russkoy tserkvi [History of Russian Church]. Valaam: Monastery Publishing, 798 p. (in Russian)
Velichko A.M. (2009) Istoria visantiyskih imperatorov [Story of Byzantine Emperors] Moscow: VIF Publishing, 447 p. (in Russian)
Copyright (c) 2015 Law. Journal of the Higher School of Economics

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.













