Constitutionalism: Problems of Methodology
Abstract
The article examines the reasons for a variety in the interpretation of constitutionalism in Russian legal literature. The author divides the views into preliminary and current. The former relate to the lack of democratic constitutional traditions in this country and of studies on the Russian constitutionalism at the time of the USSR collapse. The latter group covers the methodology of the issue: linguistic and of culture and history. The author suggests one of the material reasons for the lack of unanimity on constitutionalism is the polysemy of the underlying concept of constitution. On the other hand, constitutionalism is often identified with a proper architecture of state power and the criterion for propriety is understood in a variety of ways. The architecture implying that the power should follow a certain supreme law (idea) should be considered as a way of its legitimacy. The article considers incorrect the use of the concept of constitutionalism to define the models f power having existed many centuries or even millennia before it. However, the history of English constitutionalism confirms the possibility to widen its structure at the expense of certain feudal institutions which modified the trajectory and form of this branch. The paper shows five periods of constitutionalism. Only the first of them (until 1917) does not exceed the limits of European political and legal culture in terms of social and cultural differences between the countries where constitutionalism has been shaped. In Soviet Russia another constitutionalism was being formed as it opposed all the previous models. After WW2 (3rd period) the International Bill of Human Rights was approved which is implemented in many countries, universal and municipal international mechanisms are being created. Constitutionalism exceeds national borders and acquires the features of an international structure. The fourth period is associated with the proclamation of independence of the former colonies in Asia and Africa. Remaining obsolete pre bourgeois relations impede the competency of constitutionalism. The fifth period started after the USSR collapse and is characterized with the inconsistency of democratic principles in the constitutions and the institutions to social and cultural environment of emerging post-soviet states.
References
Anners A. (1994) Istoriya evropeiskogo prava [History of European Law]. Moscow. (in Russian)
Adu Y.N. (2012) Kontseptsiya universalizatsii mezhdunarodnogo prava prav cheloveka i pozitsii razvivayushchikhsya stran. (Avtoref. diss. kand. jurid. nauk). [The Concept of Universialization of International Law of Human Rights and the Position of Developing Countries (Summary of candidate of sciences dissertation)], Moscow.
Alexeev N.N. (1999) Sovremennoe polozhenie nauki o gosudarstve i eyo blizhaishie zadachi [Science on State at the current stage and its tactic tasks]. Russkiy narod i gosudarstvo [The Russian People and state], Moscow.
Bartold V.V. (1966) Sochineniya. Tom 6 [Works. Volume 6]. (in Russian)
Berman G. (1994) Zapadnaya traditsiya prava: epokha formirovaniya [Western Tradition of Law: Epoch of Formation]. Moscow: MGU. (in Russian)
Bondar' N.S. (1999) Prava cheloveka v teorii i praktike rossiyskogo konstitutsionalisma [Human Rights in the Theory and Practice of Russian Constitutionalism]. Rossiyskiy constitutsialism problemy i resheniya [Russian Constitutionalism: Problems and Solutions], Moscow.
Varlamova N.V. (2011) Konstitutsialism: variativnost' ponyatiya [Constitutionalism: A Variety in the Concept]. Sravnitel'noe Konstitutsionnoe Obozrenie, no 5.
Vasil'ev L.S. (2005) Istoriya religiy Vostoka [History of Eastern Religions]. Moscow. (in Russian)
Batyra K.I. (Ed.) (2002) Vseobshchaya istoriya gosudarstva i prava [Universal History of State and Law]. Moscow. (in Russian)
Grafskiy V.G. (2009) Konstitutsionalism kak predmet issledovaniya [Constitution as a Subject Matter of Research]. Pravo, no 3.
Grafskiy V.G. (2010) Konstitutsiya o konstitutsionalism v mezhdisciplinarnom vospriyatii [Constitution and constitutionalism in interdisciplinary aspect]. Proceedings of 4th Philosophy and Law Conference after V. S. Nersesyants, Moscow.
Gurevich A.Ya. (1999) Izbrannye trudy. V dvukh tomakh [Selected Works. In Two Volumes]. Saint Petersburg. (in Russian)
Dicey A.V. (1905) Osnovy gosudarstvennogo prava Angli [Introduction to the Law of the Constitution of England]. Moscow. (in Russian)
Dobrynin N.M. (2010) Dekonstitualizatsiya — ozhidaemoe ili norma zhizni? [Deconstituliazation — Anything Expected or a Norm of Life?]. Gosudarstvo i pravo, no5.
Dozhdev N.M. (2002) Rimskoe chastnoe pravo [Roman Private Law]. Moscow. (in Russian)
Egorov S.A. Konstitutsionalism v SShA: politico-praviye aspekty [US Constitutionalism: Political and Legal Aspects]. Moscow. (in Russian)
Ellinek G. (1906) Deklaratsiya prav cheloveka i grazhdanina [Declaration of the Rights of Man and of Citizen].
Ellinek G. (1906) Konstitutsiyi, ikh istoriya i znachenie v sovremennom prave [Constitutions, their History and Significance in Modern Law]. Saint Petersburg. (in Russian)
Ellinek G. (1908) Obshchee uchenie o gosudarstve [Common Theory of State]. Saint Petersburg. (in Russian)
Nersesyants VS. (Ed.) (1983) Istoriya burzhuaznogo konstitutsionalizma 17-18 veka [History of Bourgeois Constitutionalizm in the 17th and 18th centuries]. Moscow. (in Russian)
Nersesyants V.S. (Ed.) (1986) Istoriya burzhuaznogo konstitutsionalizma 19 veka [History of Bourgeois Constitutionalizm in the 19th century]. Moscow. (in Russian)
Zhidkov O.A., Krashenninikova N.A. (Eds.) (1988) Istoriya gosudarstva i prava zarubezhnykh stran. v dvukh tomakh (History of State and Law in Foreign Countries). Moscow. (in Russian)
Kolesnitskiy N.F. (1959) Issledovanie po istorii feodal'nogo gosudarstva v Germanii (9-pervaya polovina 12 veka) [Research in History of Feudal State in Germany (9th-first half of 12th century)]. Moscow. (in Russian)
Konyukhova I.A. (2000) Problemy stanovleniya konstititsionalizma v sovremennoy Rossii [Problems of the development of constitutionalizm in Russia]. Konstitutsionno-pravovaya reforma v Rossiyskoy Federatsii (ed.Yu.S. Pivovarov), Moscow.
Krashenninikova N.A. (2011) Pravovaya kul'tura sovremennoy Indii [Legal Culture in Modern India]. Moscow. (in Russian)
Kruss V. (1998) Konstitutsionalizm i filosofiya prava: k poznavaniyu problem [Constitutionalizm and Philosophy of Law: Cognizingthe Issue]. Pravo i zhizn', no 15.
Mamitova N.V. (2006) Rossiiskiy konstitutsionalizm: istoriya i sovremennost'. (Avtoref. diss. doct. jurid. nauk). [Russian Constitutionalizm: History and Modernity. (Summary of doctor of sciences dissertation)], Moscow.
Mamut L.S. (2008) Legitimatsiya gosudarstva [Legitimacy of state]. Proceedings of Philosophy and Law Conference after V. S. Nersesyants, Moscow.
Muromtsev G.I. (2005) O nekotorykh aspektakh struktury prava. Proceedings of Interuniversity Conference Struktura Prava: voprosy teorii, istorii i metodologii., April 7, 2004, Moscow.
Muromtsev G.I. (1989) O nekotorykh osobennostyakh traditsionnogo prava v razvivayushchikhsya stranakh Azii i Afriki [On the Peculiarities of Traditional Law in Developing Countries in Asian and African Countries]. Sovetskoe Gosudarstvo i Pravo, no 6.
Lukasheva E.A. (Ed.) (1996) Obshchaya teoriya prav cheloveka [Common Theory of Human Rights]. Moscow. (in Russian)
Ozhegov S.I. (1981) Slovar' russkogo yazyka [Dictionary of the Russian Language]. Moscow. (in Russian)
Pastukhov V. (2011) Revolyutsiya i Konstitutsiya [Revolution and Constitution]. Sravnitel'noe konstitutsionnoe obozrenie, no 1.
Pivovarov Yu.S. (1994) Politicheskaya kul'tura poreformennoy Rossii [Political Culture of Russia under Reform]. Moscow. (in Russian)
Tunanov V.A. (Ed.) (1982) Praktika burzhuaznogo konstitutsionalizma [Bourgeois Constitutionalism in Practice]. Moscow.
Romashov R.A. (1997) Konstitutsionnoe gosudarstvo (istoriya, sovremennost', perspektyvy razvitiya) [Constitutional State (History, Modernity, perspectives)]. Krasnoyarsk.
Starodubskiy B.A. (Ed.) (1985) Sovremenniy burzhuazniy konstitutsionalizm v teorii i praktike [Modern Bourgeois Constitutionalism in Theory and Practice]. Sverdlovsk.
Zhidkov O.A. (1993) Soedinennie shtaty Ameriki. Konstitutsiya i osovnie zakonodatel'nie akty [The USA. Constitution and the Major Legislative Acts]. Moscow. (in Russian)
Sklifus S.V. (2009) Legitimatsiya gosudarstvennoy vlasti v Rossiyskoy Federatsii: voprosy teorii. (Avtoref. diss. Kand. Jurid. Nauk). [Legitimacy of State Power in the RF: theoretical issues. (Summary of candidate of sciences dissertation)]. Belgorod.
Stepanov I.M. (1987) Sotsialisticheskiy konstitutsionalizm: sushchnost', opyt, problem [Socialistic Constitutionalism: identity, practice, problems]. Sovetskoe gosudarstvo i pravo, no 10.
Stepanov I.M. (1990) Konstitutsionalizm: tsennosti kul'tury ili kul'tura tsennostey. Proceedings of Soviet-British symposium, Moscow, Institute of State and Law.
Strashun B.A. (2011) Konstitutionalizm: ideal, real'nost' i vozmozhniye perspektivy [Constitutionalism: Ideal, Reality and Possible Perspectives]. Sravnitel'noe konstitutsionnoe obozrenie, no 5.
Krashenninikova N.A. (Ed.) (2004) Khrestomatiya po istorii gosudarstva i prava zarubezhnykh stran [Reader in the History of State and Law of Foreign Countries]. Moscow. (in Russian)
Chetvernin V.A. (1993) Demokraticheskoe konstitutsionnoe gosudarstvo: vvedenie v teoriyu [Democratic Constitutional State: Introduction into the Theory]. Moscow. (in Russian)
Bondar N.S. (2012) Modern Russian Constitutionalism: Philosophical Conseptualisation in Light of Constitutional Justice. Law. Journal of Higher School of Economics. Annual review.
Endicott T.A.O. (2012) The Future of Human Rights Law. Law. Journal of Higher School of Economics. Annual review.
Martenson J. (2005) Foreword. Lawson E. Encyclopedia of Human Rights. New York.
(1973) The Cambridge History of Islam. L.
Doren van. (1988) Death of African Style: the Case of S.M. Ofieno. The American journal of comparative law, no 2.
Weber M. (1968) On charisma and institution building. Chicago.
Copyright (c) 2014 Law Journal of the Higher School of Economics
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
