Legal Entity as a Means, a Method, a Instrument of Committing a Crime
Abstract
The possible criminal liability of a legal entity is the most famous dispute. Understanding the nature of the legal person as a fiction or reality is the main argument of the parties. Then other approaches to the involvement of a legal entity in criminal law began to be developed. For example, the legal entity is not considered as a perpetrator of crime, but as a means, a method, and a weapon of committing a crime. We will turn to the arguments presented in theoretical approaches on the recognition of a legal entity as a means, a method, a weapon of committing a crime, as well as judicial practice. Legal entity is proposed to be considered not as a perpetrator, but as a weapon of a crime based on the fictitious nature. Opponents of this approach argue that a weapon is always a real material object. However, judicial practice generally shows the recognition of a legal entity as a weapon of a crime. In this case, if an organization is used as a weapon, the reality of its activity is not taken into account. The focus is made only on the individual — the perpetrator of the crime, and the legal entity and its autonomy are ignored. Theoretical approaches suggest that a legal entity should be viewed as a means of committing a crime. But not the legal entity as a whole, but only the institutionallegal forms of legal entities. A legal entity is also recognized as a means of committing a crime in jurisprudence. It is argued that the infrastructure and legal structure of a legal entity is also used as a method of committing a crime. In judicial practice we see a direct indication that a legal entity has been created by an individual for the purpose of committing a crime. In this way, the theories of fiction and reality of a legal entity are used by the parties to the dispute. Courts directly indicate that the legal entity has been used as a weapon and means of committing a crime, while ignoring its autonomy and focusing on an individual.
References
Abashina L.A. (2008). Legal entity as a subject of criminal responsibility. Candidate of Juridical Sciences Summary. Moscow, 26 p. (in Russ.)
Abramyan T.A. (2018) Criminal liability of legal entities: foreign experience and prospects of introduction in Russia. Bezopasnost' biznesa=Business security, no 2, pp. 59-63 (in Russ.)
Alexandrov V. (1865) The doctrine of legal persons, according to the principles of science (discourse of a student of the Imperial Moscow University, Faculty of Law, IV course). Moscow: University printing house (Katkov and Co.), 152 p. (in Russ.)
Antonova E.Yu. (2009) Responsibility of juridical person in criminal law: arguments pros and cons. Ugolovnoe pravo = Criminal Law, no 5, pp. 4-9 (in Russ.)
Bastrykin A.I. (2015) Protection of constitutional rights of citizens as a fundamental function of the Investigative Committee of the Russian Federation. Rossijskij sledovatel' = A Russian investigator, no 11, pp. 3-6 (in Russ.)
Belousov D.M. (2015) Pressing issues of investigation into illegal transfer of assets abroad. Zakonnost' = Legality, no 3, pp. 11-14 (in Russ.)
Bogdanov E.V. (2017) The question of introducing criminal liability for legal entities: arguments against it. Vserossijskij kriminologicheskij zhurnal = All-Russian Criminological Journal, vol. 11, no 2, pp. 370-379 (In Russ.) DOI: https://doi.org/10.17150/2500-4255.2017.11(2).370-379
Gabov A.V. (2014) Theory and practice of reorganization (legal aspect). Moscow: Statute. 880 p. SPS “ConsultantPlus” (in Russ.)
Gin-Barisevichene K. (2015) The fight against one-dayers continues. EZH-YUrist = EG-Lawyer, no 29, p. 2. (in Russ.)
Golovko L.V. (2017) Deja vu: yet another argument for corporate criminal liability. Zakon = Statut, no 8, pp. 105-114. SPS “ConsultantPlus” (in Russ.)
Gervagen L.L. (1888) The development of the doctrine of the legal entity. St. Petersburg: printing house of I.N. Skorokhodov, 91 p. (in Russ.)
Ivantsov P.P. (2001) The problem of liability of legal entities in Russian criminal law. Candidate of Juridical Sciences Summary. Saint Petersburg, 23 p. (in Russ.)
Kachalov V.V. (2016) Criminal liability of legal entities: a critical analysis of arguments against. Lex russica, no 12, pp. 32-40. SPS ConsultantPlus (in Russ.)
Khlus A.M. (2018) Means of committing crimes as an element of their criminalistic structure. Rossijskoe pravo: obrazovanie, praktika, nauka = Russian law: education, practice, science, no 1, pp. 24-32. SPS Garant (in Russ.) DOI: https://doi.org/10.34076/2410-2709-2018-1-24-33
Klepitsky I.A. (2013) Criminal liability of corporations: “for” and “against”. Criminal legal impact on legal entities: materials of the Russian-German criminal law seminar (June 26, 2012). Moscow: Yurlitinform, pp. 36-47.
Komosko A.A. (2007) Criminal liability of legal entities. Candidate of Juridical Sciences Summary. Moscow, 30 p. (in Russ.)
Krokhina U.A. (2015) Improving the liability of legal persons as a means of securing the de-offshorisation of the Russian economy. Rossijskaya yustitsiya = Russian justice, no 11, pp. 41-44. SPS ConsultantPlus (in Russ.)
Kuritsina E. (2001) A legal entity as an instrument of crimes. Rossijskaya yusticiya = Russian justice, no 2, pp. 42-43. SPS ConsultantPlus (in Russ.)
Kvashis V.E., Sluchevskaya Yu.A. (2016) Institute of criminal liability of the legal entities as a new stage of development of the criminal law. Zhurnal rossijskogo prava = Journal of Russian Law, no 12 (240), pp. 79-90 (in Russ.) DOI: https://doi.org/10.12737/22723
Lebedev S.Ya. (2017) Criminal liability of a legal entity is the same legal fiction as the legal entity itself. Soyuz kriminalistov i kriminologov = The Union of Criminalists and Criminologists, no 1-4, pp. 26-32 (in Russ.)
Legal regulation of monetary circulation (Monetary law) (2016) N.M. Artemov, I.B. Lagutin, A.A. Sitnik, et al. Moscow: NORMA, 96 p. SPS Garant (in Russ.)
Lyaskalo A.N. (2017) Classification of foreign currency crimes: issues of differentiation and accumulation. Ugolovnoe pravo = Criminal law, no 5, pp. 67-76 (in Russ.)
Minin R.V. (2008) Institute of Criminal Liability of Legal Entities in Russia: problems of conditionality and regulation. Candidate of Juridical Sciences Summary. Tyumen, 22 p. (in Russ.)
Minin R.V. (2016) Formation of the list of crimes committed by legal entities. Lex russica, no 10, pp. 97-104 (in Russ.)
Rozenko S.V. (2015) The problems of classification and punishability of special elements of fraud. Ugolovnoe pravo = Criminal law, no 5, pp. 84-85 (in Russ.)
Rozhavsky Z.D. (2017) Figurehead in the context of crimes committed with the use of shell companies. Sovremennoe pravo = Modern Law, no 6, pp. 85-88 (in Russ.)
Savenkov A.N. (2016) Criminal law practices and stability of crediting system. Zhurnal rossijskogo prava = Journal of Russian Law, no 9, pp. 78-91. SPS ConsultantPlus (in Russ.) DOI: https://doi.org/10.12737/21223
Savigny F.K. (2012) The system of modern Roman Law: In 8 vols. Vol. II. Translated from German by G. Zhigulin; Edited by O. Kutateladze, V. Zubar. Moscow: Statute; Odessa: Center for the Study of Law Savigny, 573 p. SPS ConsultantPlus (in Russ.)
Sholokhov S.V. (2003) Commercial organization as an instrument of crime. Sledovatel’ = Investigator, no 6, pp. 13-14 (in Russ.)
Smirnov G. (2014) Does a legal entity have a soul? Corporations should be criminally liable on an equal basis with individuals. Yurist speshit na pomoshch' = Lawyer hurries to help, no 8, pp. 17-24 (in Russ.)
Soloviev I.N. (2016) Criminal law characteristic of art. 173.2 of the Criminal code of the Russian Federation in view of the amendments introduced by Federal law of March 30, 2015 N 67-FZ. Rossijskij sledovatel’ = A Russian investigator, no 3, pp. 34-41. SPS ConsultantPlus (in Russ.)
Soloviev I.N., Moiseenko M.A., Povetkina N.A., Ilyin A.Yu., Mironenko T.V., Ataev D.A. (2017) Identification of tax crimes: a comprehensive study. Prospect. 192 p. (in Russ.)
Sychev P.G. (2014) Property-related economic crime and processing effects. Imushchestvennye otnosheniya v Rossijskoj Federatsii = Property relations in the Russian Federation, no 12 (159). pp. 80-92 (in Russ.)
Tagantsev N.S. (1902) Russian criminal law. Lectures. The General part. 2nd ed. Saint Petersburg: University, vol. I, 815 p. (in Russ.)
Tsepov G.V. (2017) You are hit in your face, not in your passport, or: concepts of sham company, straw person and shadow director in Russian court practice. Zakon = Statut, no 6, pp. 86-100 (in Russ.)
Viskov N.V. (2006) Objects of a crime, tools and means of its committing in the aspect of solving the fate of physical evidence. Rossijskij sledovatel’ = Russian investigator, no 3, pp. 2-5 (in Russ.)
Voronkevich S.A. (2008) Criminalistic analysis of the structure of economic crimes. Pravo i demokratiya = Law and democracy, Issue 19, pp. 314-324 (in Russ.)
Yani P.S. (2015) Specific types of fraud. Zakonnost’ = Legality, no 3, pp. 47-52 (in Russ.)
Zyryanov S.M. (2015) Administrative responsibility as variety of juridical responsibility. Vestnik Moskovskogo universiteta MVD Rossii = Bulletin of the Moscow University of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia, no 6, pp. 79-85 (in Russ.)
Copyright (c) 2022 Law Journal of the Higher School of Economics
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
