Relations On Actual Upbringing of a Child: Family and Legal Institutionalization

  • Elena Komissarova Department of Civil Law, Perm State National Research University
Keywords: family education, family ties, actual upbringing of the child, family and legal status, child welfare, child-parent interaction

Abstract

Analyzing the current state of the doctrinal problem and considering actual upbringing of a child as a type of family upbringing, the author asks what requirements a relatively complete theoretical concept of the actual upbringing of a child should meet in order to recognize the problem if not solved, then at least bring research novelty to it. Its current state is seen as critical from the point of view of a set of theoretical tools, in the structure of which analysis prevails over synthesis and there is a constant immersion in reality with the issuance of recommendations to the legislator in the language of social service specialists. While the question of what is due to the current position of the legislator, who has renounced the positive status regulation of relations on the actual upbringing of the child and left them in the category of direct, science does not ask. The doctrinal attitude to such a position is usually exhausted by disagreement. Such views not only do not reflect the current social mood of state policy in matters of family and child-saving, but also inform the problem of the quality of cultural limitations, the consequence of which is the underestimation of relations on actual education as a significant intra-family educational resource. Answering the theoretical question, the author offers a more spacious view of the problem, which allows us to give it the necessary dynamics, competition of concepts, methods and methods of description. Comparing the problem under study with achievements of socio-humanitarian research surrounding it, the author finds no grounds to support the widespread scientific views that actual upbringing is a weakened and unprotected phenomenon from the point of view of the child's interests. Discussing the ways of possible legislative participation in this type of social relations, the author argues that modern legislative attempts to interfere in these relations are possible only in one direction, by giving them qualities that indicate the derivation of these relations from relations for the family upbringing of a child.

Author Biography

Elena Komissarova, Department of Civil Law, Perm State National Research University

Professor, Doctor of Juridical Sciences

References

Alferova O.S. (2011) Legal status of actual teachers. In: Family Law at the turn of the 20 and 21 centuries: to 20th anniversary of Convention of Rights of the Child. Papers of International Conference. Moscow: Statut, pp. 315-318 (in Russian)

Arnett J. (1995) Broad and Narrow Socialization: The Family in the Context of a Cultural Theory. Journal of Marriage and Family, no 3, pp. 617-728.

Boele-Woelki K., Braat B., Curry-Sumner I. (2005) European family law in action. Vol. III: Parental Responsibilities. Antwerp: Intersentia. 821 p.

Byng-Hall J. (1985) Family scripts: A useful bridge between theory and practice. Journal of Family Therapy, no 3, pp. 301-306.

Brandenburgskiy J.N. (1928) Life has its requirements. Ezhenedel'nik sovetskoy yustitsii, no 23, pp. 664-667 (in Russian)

Bulaevskiy B.A. et al. (2017) Family law: a concept of V.A. Ryasentsev. In: Ryasantsev V.A. Semeynoe pravo. Moscow: Prospect (in Russian)

Choguldurov S.B. (2015) The legal category “family and legal status of a citizen”. Actualnye problemy economiki i prava, no 3, pp. 157-163 (in Russian)

Connidis I., McMullin J. (1996) Reasons for and Perceptions of Childlessness among Older Persons: Exploring Impact of Marital Status and Gender. Journal of Aging Studies, no 3, pp. 205-222.

Ferguson N. et al. (2004) Grandparenting in Divorced Families. Bristol: Poliku Press, 176 p.

Daly M., Wilson M. (1998) Truth about Cinderella: A Darvinian View of Parental Love. L.: Weidenfeld and Nicolson, 80 p.

Desrosières A. (1978) Marché matrimonial et structure des classes sociales. Actes de la recherche en sciences sociales, vol. 20-21, pp. 97-107.

Diamond B. (1996) The Legal Aspects of Child Health Care. L.: Mossy, 245 p.

Duvernois N. (1872) The significance of Roman law for Russian lawyers. Yaroslavl: Falk, 25 p. (in Russian)

Erokhina E.V. (2016) European family law. Orenburg: University, 240 p. (in Russian)

Esping-Andersen G., Palier B. (2008) Trois leçons sur l'État-providence. Paris: Republic of Ideas, 135 p.

Godard F. (1992) La famille affaire de générations. Paris: Flammarion, 206 p.

Golovkin R.B., Anisimova A.M. (2006) The legal effect of the relationship of close persons. Vladimir: University, 168 p. (in Russian)

Kanina I.A. (2006) Private life in the sphere of law. Candidate of Juridical Sciences Thesis. Tambov, 251 p. (in Russian)

Kapitova O.V. (2009) Mechanism of alimony in the family law of Russia. Candidate of Juridical Sciences Summary. Moscow, 25 p. (in Russian)

Karapetov A.G. (2020) Commentary to Articles 1-16.1 of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation. Moscow: Logos, 469 p. (in Russian)

Korotkova L.P. (1983) Legal status of actual educators. Pravovedenie, no 3, pp. 82-85 (in Russian)

Macklin E. (1980) Nontraditional family forms: a decade of research. Journal of Marriage and Family, no 4, pp. 905-922.

Malkevich M.S. (2014) Implementation of parental rights in the case of a child living with a stepfather (stepmother), cohabitant, cohabitant. Vestnik Samarskogo universiteta, no 5, pp. 240-244 (in Russian)

Manankova R.P. (2012) Note to the concept of the draft new Family Code of the Russian Federation. Semeynoe i zhilischnoe parvo, no 4, pp. 26-41 (in Russian)

Matveev G.K. (1968) Institute of actual education of other people's children. Legal issues of the family and upbringing of children. Moscow: Yuridicheskaya literatura, pp. 97-101 (in Russian)

McCarthy J., Edwards R. (2018) Family studies: basic concepts. Moscow: HSE, 343 p. (in Russian)

Nechaeva A. M. (2012) Child and society. Sotsial'no-yuridicheskaya tetrad', no 2, pp. 5-26 (in Russian)

Rabets A.M. (2018) Alimony obligations and guardianship and guardianship: issues of coexistence. Sovremennoe pravo, no 2, pp. 25-30 (in Russian)

Segalen M., Martial A. (2013) Sociologie de la familie. Paris: Flammarion, 341 p.

Tarusina N.N. (2019) Risks of judicial discretion in family cases. Yuridicheskaya tekhnika, no 13, pp. 602-609 (in Russian)

Tarusina N.N. (2019) Judicial practice in family cases: discretion on the verge of lawmaking. Lex Russica, no 5, pp. 40-47 (in Russian)

Tatarintseva E.A. (2017) Subject structure of legal relations on the actual upbringing of a child in the light of international standards. Semeynoe i zhilishchnoe pravo, no 3, pp. 1822 (in Russian)

Tatarintseva E. A. (2018) Legal relations of upbringing of a child in the family and their formation in national family law. Moscow: Justitsinform, 134 p. (in Russian)

Voronina Z.I. (1993) Legal forms of education of children without parental care. Candidate of Juridical Sciences Thesis. Saint Petersburg, 234 p. (in Russian)

Vorozheikin E.M. (1972) Family legal relations in the USSR. Moscow: Yuriidicheskaya literatura, 336 p. (in Russian)

Zagorovsky A.I. (1909) Course of family law. Odessa: Ekonomika, 574 p. (in Russian)

Zvyagintseva L.M. (1980) Measures of protection in family law. Candidate of Juridical Sciences Summary. Sverdlovsk, 15 p. (in Russian)

Published
2021-03-16
How to Cite
KomissarovaE. (2021). Relations On Actual Upbringing of a Child: Family and Legal Institutionalization. Law Journal of the Higher School of Economics, (1), 130-153. https://doi.org/10.17323/2072-8166.2021.1.130.153
Section
Russian Law: Condition, Perspectives, Commentaries