Axiological Aspects of State Control and Supervision

  • Saniat Agamagomedova Department of State Law Subjects, Penza University
Keywords: deregulation, value, state control and supervision, values protected by law, public administration, administrative reform, objectives of control and supervisory activities

Abstract

The subject of research is state control and supervision from the point of view of axiological approaches. The first level of the latter makes it possible to determine value of state control and supervision as administrative forms; the second level forms variants of theoretical and legal substantiation of the correlation between the control and supervisory activities of the state and the totality of values protected by law. The aim of the article is to propose methodological techniques for determining the value of state control and supervision, which is understood as the importance of these institutions in the public administration system as a whole in the context of the possibility of using other administrative forms to achieve regulatory goals. The value of the control and supervisory activities of the state is substantiated from the point of view of the possibility of replacing state control and supervision with other regulatory mechanisms within the framework of deregulation processes (horizontal approach), as well as taking into account previous development of these administrative forms (evolutionary approach). Value of state control and supervision is seen as the ability to ensure the protection of legally protected values with minimal interference of public authorities in controlled activities. Value of the considered management forms is substantiated using the category of deregulation, which is understood as: process of development of a certain sphere of social relations; process of delegating state powers; trends to expanding the freedom of subjects, transition to “soft” regulation; process of reducing and simplifying administrative procedures (procedural deregulation). Determination of the value of state control and supervision is associated with the justification of the possibility of replacing these management forms with others in relation to a certain area of regulation, which determines a specific ratio of various management forms and mechanisms. From the point of view of evolutionary approach, value of state control and supervision is determined by the previous development of these administrative forms in the system of state power. Within the framework of the theoretical and legal substantiation of the category “values protected by law” in the system of state control and supervision, a variety of positions are highlighted. As a conclusion, a modern formula is proposed: state control and supervision — socially significant results — mandatory requirements — values protected by law.

Author Biography

Saniat Agamagomedova, Department of State Law Subjects, Penza University

Associate Professor, Candidate of Juridical Sciences

References

Andrushin S.A., Dadashev A.Z., Sokolovskaya E.A. (2002) Financial control in Russia: papers of round table. Moscow: Institute of Economics, 250 p. (in Russian)

Bahrah D.N., Skorohodova V.V. (2007) Delegating power functions to commercial banks. Sovremennoe pravo, no 11, pp. 2-5 (in Russian)

Big encyclopedia dictionary (1991) A. M. Prokhorov (ed.). Vol. 2. Moscow: Sovetskaya encyclopedia. 768 p. (in Russian)

Burkova A. Yu. (2020) Deregulation. Yurist, no 1, pp. 71-73 (in Russian)

Cerny G. (1991) Limits of deregulation. European journal of political research, vol. 19, pp. 173-196.

Chirkin V.E. (2009) Public power in the contemporary society. Zhurnal rossiyskogo prava, no 7, pp. 3-13 (in Russian)

Dean S. (2011) Tax deregulation. New York University law review, vol. 86, pp. 387-436.

Demin A.B. (2017) Disposition and taxation. SPS Consultant Plus (in Russian)

Dobrolubova E.I. (2016) Results and efficiency of state control in labor relations. Statistika i ekonomika, no 6, pp. 49-55 (in Russian)

Doronina N.G., Semilutina N.G. (2015) Russian modern economic law. In: Law and economic activity. A.V.Gabov (ed.). Moscow: Statute, pp. 25-35 (in Russian)

Gubin E.P. (2019) The principles of business. Business law in Russia: trends and ways of progress. Moscow: Yustitsinform, 664 p. (in Russian)

Malkov V.V. (1965) Social control in Soviet state administration. Moscow: University, 123 p. (in Russian)

Martynov A.V. (2017) New approahes to establishing guidelines for enterpreneurs. In: Law, economic progress and state regulation. V.A.Vaipan (ed.). Moscow: Justitsinform, pp. 65-89 (in Russian)

Maslennikova E.B. (2018) Study in reforming control and supervision in Russia. Vestnik RUDN, no 3, pp. 318-342 (in Russian)

Nersesiantz V.S. (2005) Philosophy of law. Moscow: Norma, 656 p. (in Russian)

Nozdrachev A.F., Zyrianov S.M., Kalmykova A.V. (2017) Reform of state and control and supervision. Zhurnal rossiyskogo prava, no 9, pp. 34-46 (in Russian)

Nureev R.M., Latov Yu.V. (2006) What dependency from the past means and how Russian economists analyze it. In: The sources: experience of exploring economics. Moscow: Ekonomika, pp. 228-255 (in Russian)

Romanovskaya O.V. (2017) Delegation of state powers in system of public law. Vestnik Permskogo Universita, no 2, pp. 143-154 (in Russian)

Salnikov M.V. (2013) Western legal tradition: values and ideals. Mir politiki i sotsiologii, no 10, pp. 170-191 (in Russian)

Talapina E.V., Efremov A.A., Cereshneva I.A. (2019) Prospects of implementing dispatched register methods for fulfilling state functions. Administrative pravo i protsess, no 11, pp. 41-44 (in Russian)

Tereschenko L.K. (2019) State regulation and deregulation in communication sphere. Zhurnal rossiyskogo prava, no 10, pp. 98-108 (in Russian)

Tonkov E.E. (2018) Creative state, alternative to corporatism. In: Law and state in the world: papers of a conference. Belgorod: GIK press, pp. 8-18 (in Russian)

Winston C. (1993) Economic deregulation: days of reckoning for microeconomists. Journal of economic literature, vol. 31, pp. 1263-1289.

Zhavoronkov S. et al. (2001) Deregulation of the Russian economy. Moscow: RAN, 70 p. (in Russian)

Zorkin V.D. (2008) Axiological aspects of Russian Constitution. Sravnitelnoe konstitutsionnoe obozrenie, no 4, pp. 7-20 (in Russian)

Yakunin V.I., Sulakhin S.S., Fonareva N.E. et al. (2009) Competition policies in the Russian Federation. Vol. 2. Moscow: Expert, 352 p. (in Russian)

Yuzhakov V.N., Dobrolubova E.I., Pokida A.N., Zybunovskaya N.V. (2017) How business feels results of state control. Moscow: Delo, 352 p. (in Russian)

Published
2021-03-16
How to Cite
AgamagomedovaS. (2021). Axiological Aspects of State Control and Supervision. Law Journal of the Higher School of Economics, (1), 37-61. https://doi.org/10.17323/2072-8166.2021.1.37.61
Section
Legal Thought: History and Modernity