Specialized State Courts — a Relevant Forum for Resolving International Commercial Disputes

  • Andrey Schukin Department of Private International Law, Institute of Legislation and Comparative Law under the Government of the Russian Federation
Keywords: international trade (commercial) courts, specialized state courts, international commercial disputes, economic component of justice, Singapore International Commercial Court, International Chamber of Paris Court of Appeal, Dubai International Financial Center courts, forum

Abstract

States in Asia, the Middle East and Europe improve their commercial contract law, reform judicial procedures and create innovative specialized courts to handle international commercial disputes so that their legal systems can play a meaningful role in the development of national economies in a globalized world. In a number of countries the creation of such specialized courts has broadened the choice of ways to protect participants in the global business community. Over the past ten to fifteen years, international trade (commercial) courts have been constituted in China, France, Kazakhstan, the Netherlands, and Singapore. New initiatives to constitute such courts are underway; for example in Switzerland this issue is on the agenda of governmental authorities. The proliferation of international trade (commercial) courts in Europe, some Asian countries and other regions of the world raises considerable interest among an academic community as well as practitioners. This article provides an overview, based on foreign sources, of the procedure for resolving international commercial disputes by specialized courts. It identifies their key features (also in terms of procedural innovations) and the main reasons for their creation within the legal systems of individual states. The growing number of specialized courts, which adjudicate international commercial disputes, is conditional due to a number of reasons. Among them there are: 1) the need to strengthen the national economy, ensuring its competitiveness on a global scale; 2) increased competition for legal services markets; 3) the interest in ensuring the rule of law in international trade and financial activities; 4) the specialization of judicial activity; 5) increasing the prestige and reputation of national law in international markets. The formation of international trade (commercial) courts is an example of states support their economies in the arena of international business by using their power in the form of the judicial system, offering appropriate comfort, benefit, and advantage.

Author Biography

Andrey Schukin, Department of Private International Law, Institute of Legislation and Comparative Law under the Government of the Russian Federation

Leading Researcher, Candidate of Juridical Sciences

References

Bauw E. (2019) Commercial Litigation in Europe in Transformation: The Case of the Netherlands Commercial Court. Erasmus Law Review, vol. 12, no 1, pp. 15-23.

Bechtold S., Frankenreiter J., Klerman D. (2019) Forum Selling Abroad. Southern California Law Review, vol. 92, no 3, pp. 487-556.

Blair W. (2019) The New Litigation Landscape: International Commercial Courts and Procedural Innovations. International Journal of Procedural Law, no 2, pp. 212-234.

Get'man-Pavlova I.V., Kasatkina A.S., Filatova M.A. (2017) The International civil procedure. Moscow: Yurait, 271 p. (in Russian)

Gramckow H., Walsh B. (2013) Developing Specialized Court Services: International Experiences and Lessons Learned.

Hess B. (2017) The Justice Initiative Frankfurt am Main. Available at: http://conflictoflaws.net/2017/the-justice-initiative-frankfurt-am-main-2017-law-made-in-frankfurt/ (дата обращения: 30.03.2021)

Hess B., Boerner T. (2019) Chambers for International Commercial Disputes in Germany: The State of Affairs. Erasmus Law Review, vol. 12, no 1, pp. 33-41.

Huo Z., Yip M. (2019) Comparing the International Commercial Courts of China with the Singapore International Commercial Court. International and Comparative Law Quarterly, vol. 68, issue 4, pp. 903-942.

Isidro M. (2020) New Courts for International Commercial Disputes in Germany. Available at: https://eapil.org/2020/11/23/new-courts-for-international-commercial-disputes-in-germany/comment-page-1/ (дата обращения: 30.03.2021)

Katz J. (2012) Access to Justice from the Perspective of the Commercial Community: Judicial Specialization. Auckland University Law Review, vol. 18, pp. 37-46.

Khabrieva T.Y., Doronina N.G. (2011) Legal prerequisites for the creation of an international financial center in Russia. International financial center in Russia: economic problems and legal solutions. Moscow: Delo, pp. 253-274 (in Russian)

Kramer X., Sorabji J. (2019) International Business Courts in Europe and Beyond: A Global Competition for Justice? Erasmus Law Review, vol. 12, no 1, pp. 1-9.

Ostrager B. (2020) New York's Commercial Division: The Premier Forum for the Resolution of International Business Disputes. New York State Bar Journal, no 4, pp. 16-19.

Rowan S. (2017) The New French Law of Contract. International and Comparative Law Quarterly, vol. 66, no 4, pp. 805-832.

Sharar Z. (2020) A Comparative Guide to the Proceedings of a Case in the Qatar International Court and in the Qatar National Courts. Qatar Business Law Review, no 2, pp. 34-37.

Silvestri E. (2014) Judicial Specialization: in Search of the ‘Right' Judge for Each Case? Russian Law Journal, issue 4, pp. 165-175.

Steel W. (2015) Judicial Specialization in a Generalist Jurisdiction: Is Commercial Specialization within the High Court Justified? Victoria University of Wellington Law Review, vol. 46, pp. 307-360.

Themeli E. (2018) The Great Race of Courts: Civil Justice System Competition in the European Union. Doctoral Thesis. Rotterdam, 441 p.

Themeli E. (2019) Matchmaking International Commercial Courts and Lawyers' Preferences in Europe. Erasmus Law Review, vol. 12, no 1, pp. 70-81.

Thomas J. (2017) Keeping Commercial Law Up to Date. Available at: https://www.judi-ciary.uk/wp-content/uploads/2017/05/lcj-aston-university-speech-8-march-2017.pdf (дата обращения: 30.03.2021)

Walker J. (2019) Specialized International Courts: Keeping Arbitration on Top of its Game. International Journal of Arbitration, Mediation and Dispute Management, vol. 85, no 1, pp. 2-23.

Woolf G. (2019) A Vision of the AIFC Court. Nur-Sultan: AIFC, 308 p. (in Russian)

Yakovlev V.F. (2013) Selected Works. Vol. 3: Arbitration Courts: Formation and Development. Moscow: Statut, 749 p. (in Russian)

Yip M. (2019) The Singapore International Commercial Court: The Future of Litigation? Erasmus Law Review, vol. 12, no 1, pp. 82-97.

Published
2021-03-18
How to Cite
SchukinA. (2021). Specialized State Courts — a Relevant Forum for Resolving International Commercial Disputes. Law Journal of the Higher School of Economics, (3), 175-207. https://doi.org/10.17323/2072-8166.2021.3.175.207
Section
Law in the Modern World