Individual and Collective Self-Defence as Elements of Collective Security System

  • Kira Sazonova Department of State Studies and Law, the Russian Presidential Academy of National Economy and Public Administration
Keywords: international law, states, safety, Self-defence, individual and collective self-defence, collective security system

Abstract

One of the fundamental rights codified in the UN Charter is an integral right to individual and collective self-defence. Together with the sanctioned by the UNSC peace-making efforts, this right is an exception to the use of force principle the in international law. The complexity of self-defence is that implementing the right to individual and collective self-defence represents the use of force, which may lead to abuse and exceeding the limits of self-defence. Hence, the grounds and limits of self-defence require additional research to avoid any possible ambiguities in the application of collective security system when applying this right. Currently both Russian and foreign international law doctrine lacks a single approach. However, legal codification of key parameters of self-defence will allow specifying limits within which self-defence is a legal implementation of the right of a state. This step would promote to improving legal basis of the institution of responsibility of states for wrongful use of force within the right of international responsibility. Currently, the term self-defence is interpreted widely and legal academics do not strive for making it clarified. The problem under discussion is also relevant as the right of states to individual and collective self-defence plays an important role in strengthening the current system of universal collective security ensured by the UN and regional systems of collective security. Hence, one of the aims of the author is to analyze the position taken by the right of states to individual and collective self-defence. As this system is intended to minimize the use of force in international relations, it is crucial to exclude controversial aspects relating to implementing force the rights of states to individual and collective self-defence to avoid the grounds for the collective defence system.

Author Biography

Kira Sazonova, Department of State Studies and Law, the Russian Presidential Academy of National Economy and Public Administration

Assistant professor,  Candidate of Law, Candidate of Political Science

References

Dogovor ob otkaze ot voyni v kachestve orudiya natsional'noy politiki (Pakt Briana — Kelloga). Parizh, 27 avgusta 1928 g. [General Treaty for Renunciation of War as an Instrument of National Policy. The Kellogg-Briand Pact]. Available at: http://zaki.ru/pagesnew.php?id=1500 (accessed 09.09.2013)

Diplomaticheskii slovar' [Diplomatic dictionary] (1986). Moscow, 752 p.

Itogovyi document Vsemirnogo sammita OON 2005 g. Prinyat resolutsiyey no 60/1 General'noy assamblei OON ot 16. 09 2005. [World Summit Outcome 2005] Available at: http://www.un.org/ru/documents/decl_conv/declarations/outcome2005_ch3.shtml (accessed 09.09.2013)

Bowett D. (1958) Self-Defence in International Law. London, Springer, 294 p.

Fateev K. (2005) Obespecheniye voennoy bezopasnosti Rossiyskoy Federarsii: teoriya I praktika pravovogo regulirovaniya [Ensuring Military Security of the Russian Federation: Theory and Practice of Legal Regulation]. Moscow, Za prava voennosluzhaschykh, p. 467.

Ferdross A. Mezhdunarodnoye pravo [International Law]. Moscow, Mezhdunarodniye otnosheniya, 652 p.

Gray C. (2000) International Law and the Use of Force. N.Y., p. 430.

Green L. (1999) Essays on the Modern Law of War. N.Y, p. 604. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1163/9789004640245

Gromyko A. (ed.) (1986) Diplomaticheskii slovar' [Diplomatic Dictionary]. Moscow, Mezhdunarodnye otnosheniya, p. 752.

Kelsen H. (1932) Unrecht und Unrechtsfolge im Volkerrecht. Zeitschrift für offentliches Recht. Bd. XII. Nr. 4. Springer. pp. 481-608.

Krisch N. (2001) Self-Defence and Collective Security. Beitrage zum auslandischen offentlichen Recht und Volkerrecht. Band 151. pp. 405-412.

Lukashuk I. (ed.) (1990) Kurs mezhdunarodnogo prava. T. 4 [Course on international law. V. 4]. Moscow, Moscow State University, 272 p.

Lukashuk I. (2005) Mezhdunarodnoye pravo [International Law]. Moscow, Wolters Kluwer, 432 p.

Maleev Yu. (2004) Reabilitatsiya adekvatnogo I proportsional'nogo primeneniya sily [Rehabilitation of Adequate and Proportionate Use of Force]. Moskovskii zhurnal mezhdunarodnogo prava — Moscow journal of international law no 3(55), pp. 31-47.

Martens F. (1905) Sovremennoe mezhdunarodnoepravo tsvilizovvannykh narodov [Modern International Law of Civilized Peoples]. Saint Petersburg, A.Benke, 686 p.

Orbelyan A. (2010) Stanovlenie i razvitie instituta samooborony v mezhdunarodnom prave [Formation and Development of the Institution of Self-defence in International Law]. Yerevan, Yerevan State University, pp. 150-167.

Skakunov E. (1973) Samooborona v mezhdunarodnom prave [Self-defence in International Law]. Moscow, Mezhdunarodniye otnosheniya, 176 p.

Sobakin V. (1962) Kollektivnaya bezopasnost' — garantiya mirnogo sosuschestovaniya [Collective Security — Guaranty of Peaceful Coexistence]. Moscow, Mezhdunarodniye otnosheniya, p. 518.

Tuzmukhamedov B. (2009) Predely samooborony [Limits of Self-defence]. Available at: http://www.ng.ru/politics/2004-09-29/2_predel.html (accessed 12.06.2013)

Ushakov N. (1997) Pravovoe regulirovaniye ispol'zovaniya sily v mezhdunarodnykh otnosheniyakh [Legal Regulation of Using Force in International Relations]. Moscow, IGPAN RAN, 96 p.

Published
2013-02-11
How to Cite
SazonovaK. (2013). Individual and Collective Self-Defence as Elements of Collective Security System. Law. Journal of the Higher School of Economics, (3), 108-117. https://doi.org/10.17323/2072-8166.2013.3.108.117
Section
Russian Law: Condition, Perspectives, Commentaries