Restrictive Conditions in Employment Agreements

  • Evgeniya V. Obukhova National Research University Higher School of Economics
Keywords: restrictive covenants, employment agreement, freedom of contract, dismissal initiated by employee, competition, freedom of labor

Abstract

During working activity, employee accesses commercially valuable information on the employer including the specifics of organizational structure, business, client base etc. The interest of the employer to keeping such information is evident. Cessation of labour relations may involve risks: besidedirect damages which may reach six annual salaries of an employee dismissal may result in losing goodwill, competition with the former employee, stealing clients and other employees. Abroad, rightsand legal interests of employer are seriously protected in the event of terminating work agreement. Minimizing risks of the employer is reached by various ways in particular by including in employment agreement restrictive covenants forbidding the employer to perform certain activity after terminating the work agreement. The range of restrictive covenants used abroad is wide: bans to compete with the employer, employment restrictions on a certain territory, ban on stealing clients and colleagues etc. In turn, Russian legislation provides a relatively narrow range of tools to solve similar issues. However, the number of court disputes on introducing loyalty bonuses, non-competition and other restrictions grows. The aim of the paper is to outline some ways of solving issues on the competition between employee and employer in some foreign countries, criteria considered by court when assessing the efficiency of restrictive covenants. Besides, the paper presents approaches to regulating this sphere of Russian law and trends in legal practice.

Author Biography

Evgeniya V. Obukhova, National Research University Higher School of Economics

Postgraduate Student, Civil and Entrepreneurial Law Department, National Research University Higher School of Economics. Address: 20 Myasnitskaya Str., Moscow, 101000, Russia. E-mail: obukhovajane@mail.ru; eobuxova@hse.ru

References

Bowie A. (2014) Restrictive Covenants Under New York Law. New York Law Journal, pp. 269-306.

Demidov N.V. (2015) Trudovoe pravo Rossii: sistemnye problemy istorii i sovremennosti [Russian Labor Law: System Issues in History and Modernity]. Zhurnal rossiyskogo prava, no 11, pp. 106-113.

Ershova E.A. (2013) Gudvill biznesa [Business Goodwill]. Moscow: Statut, 223 p. (in Russian)

Eylert M. (2006) Non-Competition Clauses in Labor Contracts. Available at: http://www.ilo.org/wcmsp5/groups/public/---ed_dialogue/---dialogue/documents/meetingdocument/wcms_159962.pdf (accessed: December 1, 2015)

Kamerling A. (2007) Restrictive Covenants under Common and Competition Law. London: Sweet and Maxwell, 538 p.

Karapetov A.G., Savel'ev A.I. (2012) Svoboda dogovora i ee predely [Freedom of Contract and its Limits]: T.1. Teoreticheskie, istoricheskie i politiko-pravovye osnovaniya printsipa svobody dogovora i ego ogranicheniy [Vol. 1. Theoretical, Historical and Political Fundamentals for Freedom of Contract and its Limitations]. Moscow: Statut, 452 p. (in Russian)

Kiselev A. (2013) Naem i uvol'nenie po-finski [Employing and Dismissing in Finnish Fashion]. EZh-Yurist, no 21, pp. 15-16.

Knyazeva N.V., Mokhnatova E.A. (2011) Intellektual'nyy potentsial personala: otbor, otsenka, upravlenie [Intellectual Potential: Selection, Choice and Management] Auditorskie vedomosti, no 9, pp. 41-51.

McGregor A. Garden Leave and Post Termination Restraints. Their Interaction and Legal Problems Generated. Available at: URL: http://www.11kbw.com/articles/docs/PostTermsandGardenAMcG.pdf (accessed: December 1, 2015)

Nazmetdinov R. (2013) Pravovoe regulirovanie rabochego vremeni v Soedinennykh Shtatakh Ameriki [Legal Regulation of Working Time in the United States of America]. Kadrovik, no 5, p. 68-71.

Rogova Yu.V. (2015) Dogovor kak sredstvo obespecheniya stabil'nosti grazhdanskogo oborota [Agreement as a Means of Stable Civil Transaction]. Moscow: Statut, 144 p. (in Russian)

Sandeen S. (ed.) (2014) Trade Secrets and Undisclosed Information. Cheltenham: Elgar, 946 p.

Sharma G. (2012) Garden Leave Clause: Restrictive Covenant in Employment Contracts (with Reference to its Applicability in India). Available at: URL: http://ssrn.com/abstract=2141186; http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2141186 (accessed: December 1, 2015)

Stanton A., Kobus J. (2011) Non-Compete vs. Non-Solicitation — Every Business Person Should Know the Difference. Available at: URL: http://www.burkelaw.com/News/Non+compete+vs+Non+solicitation+-+Every+Business+Person+Should+Know+the+Difference (accessed: December 1, 2015)

Wacke А. (1993) Freedom of Contract and Restraint of trade clauses in Roman and Modern Law. Law and History Review, vol.11, no 1, pp. 1-19.

Published
2016-02-23
How to Cite
ObukhovaE. V. (2016). Restrictive Conditions in Employment Agreements. Law. Journal of the Higher School of Economics, (2), 27-35. https://doi.org/10.17323/2072-8166.2016.2.27.35
Section
Russian Law: Condition, Perspectives, Commentaries