Muslim Law in the Context of Law-Genesis
Abstract
The subject of this article is actually first of all in consequence of insufficient investigation of a general theoretical conception of the law-genesis in the frame of which the formation of the Muslim law can prove its correctness. Conception prevailing in Russian legal literature and proceeding from the inseparable connection between state- and law-genesis is “stall” in some aspects of this problem. The clarification of a reason for this situation is one ofthe purposes of this article. The other purpose is the attempt to mark a methodology of the investigation of a problem of a law-genesis — on its theoretical level and in reference to Muslim law. Author examines law-genesis in the context of a world evolution. In the frame of this approach to social factors of the origin of the law preceded the natural factors of the same character and a thesis about the origin of the law at the same time as a human society stands as a starting. A conclusion that the law-governed nature of the development of the behavior and of the mechanisms of its regulation was formed into the natural stage of the world evolution -this conclusion acquires the most importance. They arise in the form of reflexes and then were perceived by the sincrete norms of the custom mononorm. In his way sharia as a basis of the Muslim law perceived in general in the new historical condition thus parameters of the mononorm as over natural character of its origin, sincretism of its norms, immutable, the absence of the necessity of the apparat which is possible to compel to observe the norms of the charia. A structure of the Muslim law reflects also an influence of the conceiving civilization. Typically various character ofthis legal cultures stipulates the necessity of the religious-legal schools as a connection section between immutable norms of the sharia and the changeable social relations. Asa result, the Islamic jurisprudence, or fikh appears. In a character of functions of this schools which are direct to maintenance in working conditions of the sincret norms of the sharia author sees the law-governed phenomenon which is typical for an early-class system of law and not enough theoretically comprehend. Today the structure of the Muslim law includes also any elements of the early-class epoch.
References
Alekseev S.S. (1994) Theory of law. Moscow: BEK, 221 p. (in Russian)
Alekseev V.V. (ed.) (2014) Theory and methodology of law. Volgograd: Uchitel', 503 p. (in Russian)
Allott A.N. (1965) Law and language. London: University press, 31 p.
Arsanukaeva M. (2004) Mashaby — schools of Islamic legal thought. Sovremennoe parvo, no 7, pp. 52-60 (in Russian)
Arsanukaeva M. (2004) Sunni Mashaby: origin and development. Religiya i pravo, no 2, pp. 24-26 (in Russian)
Artemov V.U. (2007) Sources and doctrines of Muslim law. Zhurnal rossiyskogo prava, no 3, pp. 128-136 (in Russian)
Belomestnova N.V. Plebanek O. V. (2012) Conscience and culture in scholar worldview. Voprosy filosofii, no 10, pp. 43-52 (in Russian)
Chestnov I.L. (2006) Historical causes of state and law. In: Teoriya gosudarstva i prava. Saint Petersburg: Peter Press, pp. 41-95 (in Russian)
Darvin Ch. (1986) Origin of Species by Means of Natural Selection. Moscow: Prosve-chenie, 484 p. (in Russian)
Drobischevskiy S.A. (1994) Political organization of society and law. Doctor of Juridical Sciences Summary. Saint Petersburg, 40 p. (in Russian)
Dumanov H.M., Perschiz A.I. (2000) Mononorm and initial law. Gosudarstvo i pravo, no 1, pp. 98-104 (in Russian)
Engels F. (1989) Origin of family, private property and state. Moscow: Politizdat, 240 p. (in Russian)
Gegel G. (2009) Philosophy of law. Moscow: Nauka, 415 p. (in Russian)
Gurevich A.Ya. (1984) Categories of medieval culture. Moscow: Nauka, 350 p. (in Russian)
Ismaylov A.Sh. (2009) Mashaby in Islam. Islamovedenie, no 2, pp. 15-27.
Jung K. (1998) Psychology of the Unconscious. Moscow: Pedagogika, 397 p. (in Russian)
Kartaschov V N. (2018) State and law theory. Yaroslavl: University, 359 p. (in Russian)
Khaidarova M.S. (1984) Major theories and schools in Muslim law. Muslim Law (structure and institutions). V.E. Chirkin, L.R. Sjukiyainen (eds.). Moscow: Nauka, pp. 38-48 (in Russian)
Khallyak V. (2020) History of Islamic legal theories. Moscow: HSE, 463 p. (in Russian)
Kolesnikov P.M. (2012) Muslim law in legal systems of the Middle East. Moscow: Russian Legal Academy, 142 p. (in Russian)
Komarov S.A. (1998) General theory of state and law. Moscow: Jurist, 406 p. (in Russian)
Korel'skiy V.M., Perevalov V.D. (1998) Theory of state and law. Moscow: Nauka, 450 p. (in Russian)
Kubbel L. (1988) Essays on political ethnography. Moscow: Nauka, 268 p. (in Russian)
Kulanzh F. de (1903) Ancient civil community. Moscow: Sytin, 405 p. (in Russian)
Leontyev A.N. (1971) Necessities, motives and emotions. Moscow: MGU, 65 p. (in Russian)
Lotman Yu.M. (1978) Phenomenon of culture. Uchenie trudi Tartusskogo universiteta, no 10, pp. 3-17 (in Russian)
Machin I.F. (1999) On the origin of law. In: Issues of theory state and law. M. N. Marchenko (ed.). Moscow: MGU, pp. 81- 99 (in Russian)
Maltsev G.V. (1999) (a) Customary theory and common law. In: Law in Russia: theory, history and applying. Rostov: University, pp. 7-94 (in Russian)
Maltsev G.V. (1999) (b) Origin and early forms of law and state. In: Aspects of theory of state and law. V. S. Nersesjants (ed.). Moscow: Norma, pp. 27-115 (in Russian)
Morozova L.A. (2015) Theory of state and law. Moscow: Yurist, 414 p. (in Russian)
Perschiz A.I. (1979) Aspects of normative ethnography. Issledovaniya po obschei etnografii. Moscow: Nauka, pp. 210-240 (in Russian)
Pigolkin A.S. (ed.) (2008) General theory of law. Moscow: Prospekt, 485 p. (in Russian)
Piotrovskiy M.B. (2008) Fikh. Schariat. Islam. A manual. Moscow, pp. 110-111, 132-133 (in Russian)
Rasskasov L.S. (2015) Theory of state and law. Moscow: 650 p. (in Russian)
Roe M. (2019) Islamic law: history and modern times. Moscow: Medina, 576 p. (in Russian)
Rubinschtein S.L. (2015) Basics of psychology. Saint Petersburg: Piter, 705 p. (in Russian)
Saidov A.H. (2008) Hidoya by Burharuddin Marginani as a unique juridical monument of Islam. Moscow: Wolters Kluwer, pp. 15-49 (in Russian)
Sechenov I.M. (1952) Selected works. Moscow: Meditsina, 235 p. (in Russian)
Sinitsina I.E. (1978) Customary law in modern Africa. Moscow: Nauka, 285 p. (in Russian)
Sukiyainen L.R. (1991) Al-Fikh. Sharia. In: Islam. Encyclopedia. Moscow: Medina, pp. 254-257, 292-294 (in Russian)
Sukiyainen L.R. (2018) Fiqh as a reflection of legal features of Islamic law. Pravo. Zhurnal Vysshey shkoly ekonomiki, no 3, pp. 50-80 (in Russian)
Sukiyainen L.R. (2001) Fetva. Fiqh. Shariat. In: Yuridicheskaya entsiklopediya. Moscow: Yurist, pp. 1153-1156, 1197-1198 (in Russian)
Sukiyainen L.R. (2019) Fiqh as a source of modern law in Arabic countries]. Pravo. Zhur-nal vysshey shkoly ekonomiki, no 4. pp. 222-245 (in Russian)
Sukiyainen L.R. (1997) Schariat and muslim legal culture. Moscow: Nauka, 99 p. (in Russian)
Schalyutin B.S. (2011) Genesis of law as a factor of the development of society and humanity. Voprosi filosofii, no 11, pp. 51-62 (in Russian)
Valeev L.Zh. (1974) Common law and initial stages of its genesis. Pravovedenie, no 6, pp. 71-79 (in Russian)
Vasilyev L.S. (1999) A history of Eastern religions. Moscow: Nauka, 415 p. (in Russian) Vengerov A.B. (1983) Ethnography and archeology for legal science. Sovetskoe gosu-darstvo i pravo, no 3, pp. 28-36 (in Russian)
Viljunas V.K. (1986) Psychological mechanisms of biological motivation. Moscow: MGU, 207 p. (in Russian)