On the Development of an Interdisciplinary Concept of Anti-Corruption Compliance in the Russian Federation

  • Yury Garmaev Buryat State University
  • Eduard Ivanov National Research University Higher School of Economics
  • Sergey Markuntsov National Research University Higher School of Economics
Keywords: anti-corruption, anti-corruption compliance, anti-corruption education, compliance, corporate sector, corruption crime, corruption offences, corruption prevention

Abstract

Since the beginning of the 21st century, companies from various parts of the world have been actively implementing an anti-corruption compliance. This process did not leave aside Russian, primarily large, enterprises. Under their influence, the implementation process gradually started in small and medium size enterprises that often act as suppliers or service providers. The role of anti-corruption compliance as a mechanism for protecting companies from corruption offences and other misconduct should be not underestimated. At the same time, the authors noted that many largest international enterprises that invest enormous funds in designing and implementing compliance programmes are not able to prevent wrongdoing of managers, employees and third parties. As a result, these enterprises pay huge penalties to resolve anti-corruption laws violations. Based on the results of the study, the authors come to the conclusion that anti-corruption compliance should not be limited to a set of management processes and formal standards. Anticorruption compliance programmes and training should have a meaningful filling aimed at preventing corruption offences. The article proposes and substantiates the idea of developing an interdisciplinary concept of anti-corruption compliance in the Russian Federation, based on the use of the achievements of the sciences of international law, criminal law, criminal procedure law, criminalistics and investigative activities. The authors propose own definition of the anti-corruption compliance and analyse main reasons for implementation of anti-corruption compliance in companies. Special attention is paid to distinctive features of legal regulation of the anti-corruption compliance in Russia and in foreign countries. The article contributes to the integration of main scientific definitions and concepts from criminal law and criminalistics, such as corruption crime, corruption offences and corruption risks into the concept of anti-corruption compliance system. According to the authors, interdisciplinary concept of anti-corruption compliance should create a solid basis for developing standards and recommendations for Russian companies and guidelines for judges and law enforcement officers. Many provisions could help in designing effective corporate policies and procedures, as well as training and professional development programmes on anti-corruption compliance. The concept can also be used for the development of anti-corruption cooperation within the BRICS and the Eurasian Economic Union.

Author Biographies

Yury Garmaev, Buryat State University

Professor, Chair of Criminalistic and Criminal Procedure, Buryat State University, Doctor of Juridical Sciences. Address: 24 Smolin Str., Ulan-Ude 670000, Russian Federation. E-mail: garmaeff1@mail.ru

Eduard Ivanov, National Research University Higher School of Economics

Professor, Department of International Law, Law Faculty, National Research University Higher School of Economics, Doctor of Juridical Sciences. Address: 20 Myasnitskaya Str., Moscow 101000, Russian Federation. E-mail: eaivanov@hse.ru

Sergey Markuntsov, National Research University Higher School of Economics

Professor, Department of Court Proceedings and Criminal Law, Law Faculty, National Research University Higher School of Economics, Doctor of Juridical Sciences. Address: 20 Myasnitskaya Str., Moscow 101000, Russian Federation. E-mail: smarkuntsov@hse.ru

References

Alistarchov V. (2019) Protection mechanisms for entrepreneurs at the stage before initiating a criminal case. Administrativnoe pravo, no 2, pp. 89-96 (in Russian)

Aschaffenburg G. (2011) Crime and the fight against it: Criminal psychology for doctors, lawyers and sociologists. Moscow: INFRA-M, 241 p. (in Russian)

Babaev M.M. (2018) Risks as a component of the determination complex of crime. Legal Science and Practice. Vestnik Academii MVD, no 1, pp. 104-110 (in Russian)

Babaev M.M., Pudovochkin J.E. (2019) The phenomenon of risk in the context of preventive policy (criminal riskology). Vestnik Peterburgskogo universiteta, issue 1, pp. 136-148 (in Russian)

Baev O.J. (2009) Basics of methodology of criminal prosecution and professional protection from it. Moscow: Eksmo, 400 p. (in Russian)

Bashmakov I.S. (2007) The initial stage of investigation of corruption crimes committed by officials of local authorities. Moscow: Jurlitinform, 152 p. (in Russian)

Commentary to the Federal Law «On Combating Corruption» (2009) S.Y. Naumov, S.E. Channov, eds. Moscow: Justizinform, 272 p. (in Russian)

The Criminal Law: General Part. Special Part (1999) L.D. Gaukhman et al, eds. Moscow: Jurisprudencija, 784 p. (in Russian)

Kasantsev D.A., Kim D.V. (2011) Methods of preliminary investigation and trial in cases of commercial bribery. Moscow: Jurlitinform, 160 p. (in Russian)

Khalikov A.N. (2012) Official crimes: characteristics, investigation, prevention. Moscow: Jurlitinform, 312 p. (in Russian)

Kleymenov M.P. (2017) Criminological legislation. Vestnik Omskogo universiteta, no 1, pp. 179-184 (in Russian)

Krokhina Y.A. (2019) Legal essence of compliance control in business entities with state participation. Yuridicheskaya nauka, no 1, pp. 35-39 (in Russian)

Martsev A.I., Maximov S.V. (1989) General crime prevention and its effectiveness. Tomsk: University, 161 p. (in Russian)

Martsev A.I. (1980) Criminal liability as a means of crime prevention. Omsk: Higher Police School, 38 p. (in Russian)

Moretti D. (2018) The use of intermediaries in corrupt deals. Lessons from the Petrobraz case for compliance officers. Available at: www.iaca.int/wwwtest/media/attachments/2018/08/14/diogo_rf_paper_final_30_7_2018_format_edit.pdf (accessed: 30.07.2020)

Prevention of crimes and administrative offenses by the internal affairs bodies (2015) V.V. Kikot' et al, eds. Moscow: Juniti-Dana, 487 p. (in Russian)

Pudovochkin Y.E. (2008) Criminal law: concept, subject, method, system and tasks. In: Encyclopedia of Criminal Law. Vol. 1. Saint Petersburg: Malinin, 734 p. (in Russian)

Shchedrin N.V. (1999) Crime prevention theory. Krasnoyarsk: University, 58 p. (in Russian)

Shchepelkov V.F. (2003) Criminal law: overcoming contradictions and incompleteness. Moscow: Jurlitinform, 416 p. (in Russian)

Smakhtin E.V., Khristinina E.V. (2018) Investigation of Bribery in Higher Education: Forensic Aspects and Qualification Issues. Moscow: Jurlitinform, 208 p. (in Russian)

The Soviet criminology (1966) Karpets I.I., Kudryavtsev V.N., eds. Moscow: Juridicheskaya literatura, 320 p. (in Russian)

Stinson P. et al. (2018) To protect and collect: a nationwide study of profit-motivated police crime. Criminal Justice Studies, no 3, pp. 310-331.

Sundurov F.R. et al (2009) The Russian criminal law. General part. Moscow: Statut, 751 p. (in Russian)

Yani P.S., Prochorov N.V. (2018) Anti-corruption compliance in the criminal law sphere: a substantial element. Rossiyskaya justicia, no 9, pp. 54-57 (in Russian)

Zhalinskiy A.E. (2008) Criminal law risks: inevitable and overstated. Criminal law in anticipation of changes: theoretical and instrumental analysis. Moscow: Prospekt, pp. 242-249 (in Russian)

Published
2020-03-15
How to Cite
GarmaevY., IvanovE., & MarkuntsovS. (2020). On the Development of an Interdisciplinary Concept of Anti-Corruption Compliance in the Russian Federation. Law. Journal of the Higher School of Economics, (4), 106-128. https://doi.org/10.17323/2072-8166.2020.4.106.128
Section
Russian Law: Condition, Perspectives, Commentaries